Six Naples tours reviewed, and none of them goes into the church

All six tours on this site walk down Via San Gregorio Armeno, which costs nothing and takes ten minutes on your own. Not one of them opens the door at number 1, where the church, the cloister and the marble fountain are. So these reviews are not about access to the street. They are about what each guide adds to it, what each price actually covers, and how much evidence stands behind each score. One of the six has 1,835 ratings. One has none at all.
Working out what to book?The lane itself is free and never sold out — you can walk it at eight in the morning with nobody in it. What does sell out is the Cappella Sansevero slot next door, and what you cannot buy at the door is somebody who can tell you why the street is there at all. Both come bundled into the walking tours below, cancellable free up to 24 hours ahead.
See what the tours costHow I am sorting them
Two things decide the order, and the star rating is the second of them. The first is language, because it is the variable people miss. The most-booked tour here, and the only one that includes a Cappella Sansevero slot, is guided in Italian only. GetYourGuide prints that in a field most readers scroll past, and a 4.9 does you no good if you cannot follow the guide.
The second is how many people stand behind the number. A 5.0 from 2 ratings and a 4.9 from 1,835 are set in the same typeface and are not the same claim. I give the sample size on every page below and I say when it is too thin to lean on. The tours page puts all six side by side if you would rather compare than read.
The six

Naples: Old Town and Veiled Christ Tour
The most evidence on the site, and the only booking that includes the Cappella Sansevero, where a timed slot is compulsory. Guided in Italian only.
from €48Read the full review ›
Naples: Spaccanapoli and San Gennaro Chapel
No ratings yet. The reasons to consider it are the price, which is for the whole group up to 10 people, and a route built around the presepe.
from €54 per groupRead the full review ›
Naples Street Food Tour and Historic Center
The cheapest per person, two and a half hours from the Duomo to Port’Alba with tastings. Two ratings is not a sample, and the page says so.
from €43Read the full review ›
Naples Walking Tour and Guided Underground Ruins
Four hours, the waterfront and the decumani, with the Napoli Sotterranea ticket included. Narrow passages and stairs underground.
from €55Read the full review ›
Naples by Night: Food and Wine Walking Tour
The lowest score here, and the reason is not a fault: four hours in the evening and seven tasting stops. That suits some people and not others.
from €89Read the full review ›
Naples: Private Tour by Classic Fiat 500 or Fiat 600
A private car with a driver for five hours, hotel to hotel. The dearest thing here by a wide margin, and entry fees are extra.
from €220Read the full review ›The thing none of these six reviews can tell you
What is behind the door under the bell-tower arch. The church of San Gregorio Armeno holds 62 fresco scenes by Luca Giordano, a coffered ceiling painted by Teodoro d’Errico, the relics of Santa Patrizia and a cloister with a 16th-century marble fountain that is usually empty of people. No tour on this site enters it, so no review here can rate it. What I can tell you is that the sources disagree about the opening hours and that the telephone number is +39 081 552 0186. The church and cloister sets out the three versions of the hours and which one I would work from.
The street below it is free, public and ungated, and the workshops trade all year at roughly 09:00 to 20:00, not only at Christmas. So the question these pages answer is not how to get in. It is whether a guide is worth the money on a lane you can walk for nothing, and is it worth it gives my short answer before you read six long ones.
Frequently asked questions
Which of these tours has the most reviews behind it?
The Old Town and Veiled Christ tour, at 4.9 from 1,835 ratings. That is a score which has survived thousands of chances to slip, and it is the strongest evidence on the site by a long way. It is also guided in Italian only, which is the first thing its review deals with.
Does any of these tours take me inside the church and cloister?
No. All six walk down Via San Gregorio Armeno and none of them goes through the door at number 1. The complex is run by an active religious community with a school attached, and visits are arranged with the community rather than through a tour desk. The church and cloister has the conflicting opening hours and the phone number.
Why does one of the six have no rating at all?
Because nobody has rated it on GetYourGuide yet. I am not going to invent reassurance for it. What it does have is a price quoted for the whole group up to 10 people and a route built around the Neapolitan nativity scene, which is unusual. Its review explains who that suits.
Are these reviews independent?
Yes. I am not the monastery, not the artisans’ association, not the Comune di Napoli and not GetYourGuide. The site earns a commission when somebody books through a link, at no extra cost to the reader, which is set out on the affiliate disclosure page. It has not softened anything here: the free street is the advice on most pages, and it earns nothing.